As an Amazon Associate I may earn from qualifying purchases.
Choosing the right breast pump can make a world of difference when balancing motherhood, work, and your own well-being. With so many pumps on the market, it’s hard to know which one will work best for you. From my own experience and feedback from mom friends, I’ve put together this guide to the best and worst breast pumps to help make your choice easier. Whether you're pumping part-time or full-time, here are the top picks and the ones you might want to avoid—plus my overall favorite pump at the end.
Top 3 Best Breast Pumps
Spectra S1 Plus
The Spectra S1 Plus is a mom favorite for a reason. Known for its strong suction power, it’s an excellent choice if you’re exclusively pumping or need to pump frequently. The S1 Plus is quiet and has a rechargeable battery, so you don’t have to be tethered to an outlet. It offers adjustable settings for both suction strength and cycle speed, which is a huge advantage for comfort and efficiency. This pump mimics the natural rhythm of breastfeeding, making it feel gentler and reducing the chances of soreness.
• Pros: Strong suction, portable with a rechargeable battery, quiet operation
• Cons: A bit bulky for a portable pump
• Best For: Moms who are frequently pumping or exclusively pumping
Medela Pump In Style with MaxFlow Technology
The Medela Pump In Style with MaxFlow is a reliable choice from a trusted brand in breastfeeding products. This double-electric pump is lightweight and compact, so it’s easy to bring along in a tote bag. The MaxFlow technology is designed to be both gentle and effective, with pumping cycles that mimic a baby’s natural sucking rhythm. Moms often rave about the high-quality parts and ease of use, which is important when you’re pumping multiple times a day.
• Pros: Compact, reliable, effective pumping with MaxFlow technology
• Cons: Needs to be plugged in, which limits mobility
• Best For: Working moms who need a consistent, quality pump
Willow Go Wearable Breast Pump
If you’re on the go or need a hands-free option, the Willow Go is a fantastic choice. This wearable pump is designed to fit discreetly under your bra, letting you pump anywhere without being tied to an outlet or holding a pump. It’s quieter than most other pumps and has a spill-proof design, making it practical for moms moving around the house or working at a desk. You can connect it to an app that tracks your sessions and milk volume, which is a nice bonus.
• Pros: Hands-free, quiet, app connectivity for tracking
• Cons: More expensive, limited milk capacity per session
• Best For: Moms needing a discreet, mobile solution for on-the-go pumping
Top 3 Worst Breast Pumps
Evenflo Advanced Double Electric Breast Pump
The Evenflo Advanced Double Electric pump is often budget-friendly, but many moms report it doesn’t hold up well under regular use. The suction power is lower than other pumps, making it harder to express milk efficiently. Moms have noted that the parts are hard to clean, and the motor tends to be noisier, which can be frustrating during nighttime pumps.
• Pros: Affordable
• Cons: Poor suction, noisy, hard to clean
• Best For: Occasional use, but not recommended for exclusive pumpers
Lansinoh SmartPump 2.0
While the *Lansinoh SmartPump 2.0* offers Bluetooth connectivity and the ability to sync with an app, many moms report issues with the pump’s durability. The parts tend to wear down quickly, and the motor can lose strength over time. Additionally, the app connectivity is unreliable for some users, which can be frustrating when you’re trying to track your sessions.
• Pros: App connectivity, easy setup
• Cons: Durability issues, unreliable suction over time
• Best For: Short-term use but may not last for long-term pumping
Motif Luna
The Motif Luna is marketed as a hospital-grade pump, but it often falls short for moms who rely on regular pumping. While it initially offers strong suction, many users report that the suction weakens over time. The pump is also relatively bulky, which can make it inconvenient to carry around. Additionally, it requires an outlet, so it’s not ideal for on-the-go moms.
Pros: Affordable for a hospital-grade pump
Cons: Suction weakens over time, bulky, not portable
Best For: Home use for moms who don’t need to pump frequently
My Overall Pick: Spectra S2 Plus
After testing various pumps and gathering feedback, my personal favorite is the Spectra S2 Plus. This pump combines everything a mom needs for efficient, comfortable pumping. Like the S1 Plus, the S2 is known for its strong suction, quiet operation, and adjustable settings, but it’s even more affordable. While it doesn’t have a rechargeable battery like the S1, the Spectra S2 is perfect for home use and offers the same quality performance.
The S2 is especially great for moms who want the feel of hospital-grade power without a hospital-grade price tag. I found it incredibly helpful when I was pumping multiple times a day, and it’s been my go-to recommendation for friends who need a reliable pump without breaking the bank. You can even purchase the pump with a grey storage tote.
• Pros: Strong suction, affordable, adjustable settings for comfort
• Cons: Requires an outlet, so not as portable as some models
• Best For: Moms looking for an affordable, high-quality pump for regular use
Finding the right breast pump can make a huge difference in your breastfeeding journey. While some pumps like the Spectra S1, Medela Pump In Style, and Willow Go offer flexibility and performance, others like the Evenflo and Lansinoh SmartPump can be frustrating for regular use. For moms who want a powerful, affordable pump with comfort settings, the Spectra S2 Plus is a top choice. I hope these insights help you find the best pump for your needs—and make your breastfeeding experience smoother and more comfortable!
This post includes affiliate links, so if you choose to apply, Her & Co NYC may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.